Wednesday, July 28, 2010

So, this is your god

You hear all the time about how Church goers tend to live longer, healthier lives. What you never hear is this tid bit from a Slate.com story (emphasis mine):

Christians, of course, don't limit their prayers to the deceased—they also pray for the sick, and several recent studies have tested whether this practice contributes to recovery. The answer appears to be no.

As part of a study published in the American Heart Journal in 2006, researchers asked Christian congregations to pray for two groups of cardiac patients—the first group knew the Christians were praying on their behalf, and the second thought they might be. As a control, researchers told a third group that Christians might pray for them, but the Christians did not do so.

Mortality rates were comparable across the three groups, but the unprayed-for group experienced the fewest complications.

I'm not convinced it mattered one way or the other. The fewer complications were probably an anomoly or some other issue with the study. But if you are going on faith alone that a omnipotent, benevolent god exists, intervenes, and listens in any way to prayer, this can't be good.

Of course, maybe God knew it was a study, had fun with it, and is sitting up their laughing at us as some kind of practical joke. Since we can't know the plan the man in the sky and his super-marketer have for us, he pretty much has carte blanche to do whatever, doesn't he?

2 comments:

  1. Considering God's big thing is "having faith", he probably wouldn't want too much proof that prayer works. Convenient, huh?

    ReplyDelete
  2. He's got a great marketing department, I'll say that. Everything good, even stuff that comes from bad events, is credited to him.

    Anything that resolves itself in a bad way gets blamed on the Devil.

    Anything that doesn't fit neatly into those two categories (say, death of a relative) gets explained away as "his plan is unknowable."

    So, yeah, its convenient.

    ReplyDelete